Page 23 of 24
OG29.1,OG31.1,OG32.1-2,OG34.6 | Benign Gynaecology — Assignment
CLINICAL SCENARIO
You are presented with a clinical scenario involving a perimenopausal woman with multiple co-existing benign gynaecological conditions. You will demonstrate your ability to integrate knowledge of fibroid uterus, endometriosis, and the approach to perimenopausal heavy bleeding by constructing a systematic management plan that is evidence-based, patient-centred, and fertility-aware.
Instructions
Read the following clinical scenario carefully, then answer all sections in the order given. Use specific clinical details from the scenario to support your reasoning. Cite standard references where relevant (DC Dutta, Shaw's, FOGSI guidelines). Write in clear prose with appropriate clinical terminology.
Clinical Scenario: Mrs Priya, a 45-year-old G3P3 teacher, presents to the outpatient clinic with an 18-month history of heavy and painful menstrual bleeding, a 3 cm left-sided adnexal mass, and significant pelvic pain during periods. She reports that her periods have always been painful since her 20s, but the pain has worsened over the past two years. She underwent a tubal ligation 10 years ago. Her last cervical smear was normal. Ultrasound shows a 5 cm intramural fibroid (FIGO type 4, no submucosal extension), a 3 cm left ovarian cyst with ground-glass echoes, and endometrial thickness of 9 mm. Her haemoglobin is 9.2 g/dL. She does not desire future fertility.
Length: 1000–1400 words total across all five sections
What to Submit
Section 1: Diagnosis and Differential Diagnosis (approximately 200 words)
Guidance: Interpret the ultrasound findings systematically. Name the most likely diagnoses for the fibroid (state FIGO type and its implications), the ovarian cyst (name the ultrasound characteristic and the most probable diagnosis), and comment on the significance of the endometrial thickness in a 45-year-old perimenopause-aged woman. List two other diagnoses that should be considered in the differential for the ovarian cyst.
Section 2: Investigations (approximately 150 words)
Guidance: Outline the investigations you would order immediately and those you would plan as the next step. Include: (a) haematological investigations to address the anaemia; (b) the investigation of choice to characterise the ovarian cyst further; (c) whether the endometrial thickness of 9 mm in this patient requires tissue sampling and why; (d) any tumour marker you would check and its limitations.
Section 3: Management of the Fibroid Uterus (approximately 200 words)
Guidance: Given that Mrs Priya does not desire future fertility and has a FIGO type 4 intramural fibroid with significant anaemia, outline a stepwise management plan: (a) medical management to improve haemoglobin pre-operatively; (b) the surgical option of choice, explaining why hysteroscopic myomectomy alone would NOT be appropriate for a type 4 fibroid; (c) the alternative minimally invasive option (laparoscopic myomectomy vs. uterine artery embolisation) — compare their suitability; (d) the circumstances under which hysterectomy would be recommended to this patient.
Section 4: Management of the Left Ovarian Cyst — Likely Endometrioma (approximately 200 words)
Guidance: Assuming the left ovarian cyst is an endometrioma: (a) state the gold-standard diagnostic investigation and why TVS alone is insufficient for definitive diagnosis; (b) outline the management options — medical vs. surgical — for symptomatic endometriosis in a 45-year-old who has completed her family; (c) explain why GnRH analogues would NOT be appropriate as first-line long-term therapy in this woman and what add-back therapy means; (d) what is the risk of leaving an endometrioma untreated?
Section 5: Perimenopausal Counselling and Endometrial Sampling (approximately 150 words)
Guidance: The endometrial thickness is 9 mm in a 45-year-old perimenopause-aged woman presenting with abnormal uterine bleeding. (a) State whether endometrial sampling is indicated here and the reason — contrast this with the PMB threshold in a postmenopausal woman; (b) briefly outline the PALM-COEIN classification (2-3 sentences) as a framework for understanding the likely structural cause of her AUB; (c) if histology returns as simple hyperplasia without atypia, what is the management?
Grading Rubric — Benign Gynaecology Assignment Rubric
| Criterion | Points | Full-marks descriptor |
|---|---|---|
| Diagnostic accuracy: Correct identification of FIGO fibroid type, endometrioma characteristics, and endometrial thickness significance | 20 pts | All three diagnoses correctly identified with precise terminology (FIGO type 4, ground-glass/endometrioma, endometrial sampling indication correctly reasoned); differential for ovarian cyst is appropriate and complete |
| Investigation plan: Appropriate, sequenced investigations including haematology, imaging, tissue sampling, and tumour marker with stated limitations | 15 pts | Complete sequenced investigation plan; correct reasoning for endometrial sampling vs PMB threshold distinction; CA-125 limitations clearly stated |
| Fibroid management: Correct stepwise plan — medical pre-operative, appropriate surgical choice for FIGO type 4, comparison of myomectomy vs UAE, hysterectomy indication | 20 pts | Correct pre-operative iron/transfusion plan; clear explanation that type 4 fibroid is NOT hysteroscopic; accurate laparoscopic vs UAE comparison with fertility status considered; hysterectomy indication correctly stated |
| Endometrioma management: Gold-standard diagnosis, medical vs surgical options, GnRH analogue limitations and add-back therapy, risk of untreated endometrioma | 20 pts | Laparoscopy as gold standard correctly stated with reason TVS insufficient; clear medical-surgical comparison appropriate for age/completed family; GnRH add-back therapy correctly defined; malignant transformation and fertility/ovarian reserve risk of untreated endometrioma stated |
| Perimenopausal counselling and PALM-COEIN: Endometrial sampling rationale, PALM-COEIN summary, and management of simple hyperplasia without atypia | 15 pts | Correct distinction between perimenopause and postmenopause sampling threshold; PALM-COEIN briefly and correctly outlined; progestogen management of simple hyperplasia without atypia correctly stated |
| Communication quality: Clarity of clinical reasoning, appropriate use of terminology, logical structure, and evidence-based justification | 10 pts | Exceptionally clear, well-structured, evidence-based reasoning throughout; clinical terminology used precisely; standard references cited |
PEER REVIEW
Review your peer's submission against the rubric provided. For each criterion: (1) identify what they did well (cite specific lines); (2) identify one gap or error if present; (3) assign a score using the 5-level rubric descriptors. Write 2–3 sentences of overall feedback at the end. Be specific, constructive, and collegial — focus on the clinical reasoning, not writing style.